JAKIM and dogs

Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+0

JAKIM receives almost a billion ringgit a year from taxpayers, and I don’t know if they really have that much real work to do to warrant that kind of budget.

For example, the Director-General of JAKIM, Tan Sri Othman Mustapha, was busy few days ago beseeching Muslims not to keep dogs as pets because, according to him, Muslims are not permitted to touch dogs “for no reason”. This came about after a young Malay woman, Nurhanizah Abdul Rahman, was reported to have been keeping a stray dog as a pet.

I don’t know whether to laugh or cry when reading such statements from Muslim leaders. Don’t they have real work to do to make Muslims better equipped to face this hard world we live in?

Nurhanizah should be commended and supported for having a golden heart. She is obviously a caring and loving person who is providing a good life for her dog Bubu, and she has all the reason in the world to touch her dog.

A true Muslim is a kind and caring person. So, instead of scolding her, JAKIM should be proud of Nurhanizah’s kindness and humanity.

But let’s say that Othman is correct that it is sinful for Nurhanizah to touch a dog. Nurhanizah must be responsible for her sin, but she must manage that in her own way. She alone will bear that responsibility. Which human being, including Othman, is free from sin?

Othman should be concerned about his sins and not those of others. One does not become an angel just because one assumes the post of Director-General of JAKIM or by and serving the Prime Minister well. It’s not Othman’s business to ask dog-lovers to repent. That’s God’s business.

It appears to me that the problem with our Muslim leaders is that they like to talk about other people’s sins all the time — and not their own. They are preoccupied with the sins of others. They behave as if they themselves are free of sin, and so, every day, they tell fellow-Muslims how to lead good “sin-free” lives, as if only they know how.

This is what makes the Muslim community weak and divided. Muslim leaders are busy telling others what to do with respect to small irrelevant things when they themselves have contributed little to the development of their community.

Let God deal with the business of punishment and sin-management, and let JAKIM, for a start, concentrate on making sure that children in religious schools have proper curricula and teachers.

JAKIM can also make sure that all the zakat collected is used properly and in the best interests of the Muslim community. A proper audit on the application of collections should be thorough, and JAKIM can help streamline the administration of Muslim inheritance matters, which sometimes take years to settle because of inefficiency and bureaucratic delays. JAKIM can also make sure that the Baitul Mal organisation in each state is properly audited to prevent “leakages”.

There are many good tangible things JAKIM can do to help the Muslims other than telling them about sins. We already have enough preachers on TV and in the mosques for that.

Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+0


  1. left-footed footballer
    left-footed footballer
    July 10, 2017 at 9:03 pm

    well assuming nobody now is free from sins, should everyone just keep their mouth shut when something wrong is done? Should I do nothing when i see school kids being bullied because im not free from sins either? Let Jakim keep preaching, while at the same time improving on other things. And, totally agree with the zakat auditing.

  2. Alfred Chuah
    Alfred Chuah
    July 12, 2017 at 8:49 am

    How else to run these lap dogs without RM1billion?

  3. James Pisgah
    James Pisgah
    July 15, 2017 at 10:53 pm

    Dear Datuk Zaid if you fund my department with even at way less than half of the billion dollars, I will have all my department staff looking at the tiniest detail as to who has sinned including the coverage of the expanded zoological list of animals, otherwise where is my justification to you for your half a billion dollars? Cut this funding and you will jeopardize my salary for life.

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: